Culture and Resource Conflict: Why Meanings Matter by Douglas L. Medin

By Douglas L. Medin

In a multi-cultural society, differing worldviews between teams may end up in clash over competing values and behaviors. Nowhere is that this stress extra concrete than within the desolate tract, the place humans of other cultures hunt and fish for a similar animals. White americans are likely to see nature as anything exterior which they've got a few accountability to care for. against this, local american citizens usually tend to see themselves as one with nature. In Culture and source Conflict, authors Douglas Medin, Norbert Ross, and Douglas Cox examine the discord among whites and Menominee American Indians over searching and fishing, and within the approach, give a contribution to our knowing of ways and why cultures so frequently collide.

in accordance with specified ethnographic and experimental examine, Culture and source Conflict unearths that local American and eu American hunters and fishermen have differing approaches--or psychological models--with admire to fish and online game, and that those transformations result in false impression, stereotyping, and clash. Menominee view the perform of looking and fishing for recreation as an indication of a scarcity of recognize for nature. Whites, nonetheless, outline appreciate for nature extra on grounds of source administration and conservation. a few whites believe--contrary to fact--that local american citizens are depleting animal populations with over the top looking and fishing, whereas the Menominee protest that they just hunt what they want and make huge use in their trap. but the authors locate that, regardless of those transformations, the 2 teams proportion the basic underlying aim of maintaining fish and video game for destiny generations, and either teams see looking and fishing as deeply significant actions. At its middle, the clash among those teams is extra approximately distrust and stereotyping than genuine confrontation over values.

Combining the strengths of psychology and anthropology, Culture and source Conflict indicates how misunderstandings concerning the reasons of others may end up in hostility and clash. As debates over traditional assets rage around the globe, this targeted booklet demonstrates the stumbling blocks that has to be triumph over for various teams to arrive consensus over environmental coverage.

Show description

Read or Download Culture and Resource Conflict: Why Meanings Matter PDF

Similar human geography books

Human Geography of the UK: An Introduction

This new center textbook for introductory classes in human geography offers first- and second-year undergraduates with a accomplished thematic and neighborhood method of the altering human geography of the united kingdom on the finish of the 20th and starting of the twenty-first century. masking neighborhood, local, nationwide, ecu and international concerns, it additionally explores in a few aspect issues that are a part of the lived event of undergraduates themselves, resembling crime, unemployment, social exclusion and AIDS.

Fashioning Globalisation

Drastic alterations within the occupation aspirations of ladies within the built global have ended in a brand new, globalised marketplace for off-the-peg fashion designer outfits created through autonomous artisans. This booklet reviews on a phenomenon that turns out to exemplify the dual imperatives of globalisation and feminine emancipation.

Global geopolitics : a critical introduction

Dodds explores examples of yank geopolitical theorizing and hyperlinks those discussions to the long-lasting uncertainties of the post-September eleventh period. He additionally investigates geopolitics and its dating to globalization in addition to a few of the key concerns shaping the worldwide geopolitical stipulations.

An Historical Geography of Peiping

This publication is ready town of Peiping in China, often referred to as Beijing and Peking, and a urban of significant ancient value. Divided into 3 elements, this paintings explores Peiping first as a frontier urban at a time while the nice Wall used to be verified, from the Chou dynasty (ca. 1122—220 B. C. ) till the T’ang Dynasties as much as the Khitan profession (A.

Additional info for Culture and Resource Conflict: Why Meanings Matter

Sample text

The best predictor of whether Ladinos thought they helped or hurt a plant was its economic importance-Ladinos said they protect plants that have a cash value. The Itza' show yet a third profile in their ratings of impact on plants. 3 We looked to see what predicts their priority for protection and found two indepen­ dent factors. One was the total number of uses that the Itza' had for the plant and the other was ecological centrality, an index we developed on the basis of the results from the animal-plant interaction task reported Why Mea n i ngs Matter 19 earlier.

We be­ lieve that scientific cultural research must be able to overcome intuitive notions of culture in order to focus on causal processes associated with both stability and change within and across cultures. Cu ltu re as a Collection of Changing Norms a nd Ru les Some influential models of culture formation and evolution in biology and anthropology take a somewhat more liberal view of consensus, tak­ ing as examples of consensus group-level traits that assume cultures are integrated systems consisting of widely shared social "norms"-or "rules," "theories," "grrunmars," "codes," "systems," "models," or "world­ views"-that maintain heritable variation (Rappaport 1999; Laland, Old­ ing-Smee, and Feldman 2000; Wilson 2002).

Itza' Maya forest management is another case where framework theories and mental models are closely linked to the practices of those who hold the beliefs. Mental Models Originally our research group set out to study the cultural models of three cultural groups living off the same environment, the tropical rain forest of the Peh�n region of northern Guatemala. 2 We hypothesized that people's understanding of nature may affect how they act on it. We use the term "mental models" quite broadly to refer to how people approach and understand nature, and their beliefs about causal processes associ­ ated with it.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.01 of 5 – based on 44 votes